Although the claims of Marie-Antoinette saying ‘Let them eat cake’ can be historically described as literary fiction, the symbolic reality of her misquoted statement was accurate. Prior to the French Revolution the King of France Louis XVI and Marie-Antoinette were spending more money at a time the people of France were having trouble putting food on their plates. The French Revolution resulted in the execution of the French Monarchy as the people of France fought to have a greater say in government and wanted to be treated with greater respect. The French Revolution began in 1789 and ended in 1799.
Survey finds many Canadians believe poor are ‘part of the problem’
In Charles Dickens’ novel ‘Oliver Twist’ published in 1838 the statement that was immortalized in the film version called ‘Oliver’ is “Please Sir I want Some More” when the down-trodden Oliver goes up with an empty bowl asking for more gruel. Most of Dickens’ work, brings to the reader’s attention the various social evils, including the workhouse, child labour and inequalities of the day. Although Dickens wrote fiction his pieces are certainly a fairly accurate depiction of life in England at the time.
10 Things You Might Not Know About Poverty In Canada, October 17, 2013
The importance of history and the lessons of our ancestors is important as we try to address the increasing inequalities in today’s society. It is difficult to have discussions in regards to our current economic woes without hearing the need to reduce the fiscal deficit. The burden of reducing the deficit has gone on the backs of the workers just as in the time of the French Revolution.
According to Lemieux and Riddell’s research, incomes in Canada grew by 13.5 per cent overall since 1982, adjusted for inflation, but almost all of that went to the top 10 per cent of earners. The top 0.01 per cent of earners saw incomes grow more than 160 per cent, adjusted for inflation, during that time. Income growth was “negligible” for the bottom 90 per cent.
This Chart Pretty Much Says It All About Canada’s Income Inequality, March 4, 2014
We can set all the targets we want about reducing our monetary deficit but unless we start addressing the real issues related to our growing social inequities and deficits we will never solve what is truly ailing Canada. We need to start changing the way we look at addressing are growing fiscal responsibilities. We talk of the rising costs of health care, education, welfare, social programs but fail to discuss the symptoms associated with why these costs are going up. We need to address the symptoms not the problem thus in the end solving the problem.
We need to reduce poverty and specifically child poverty. This can be done by having meaningful well-paying jobs for workers. The wealthy are always stating they are paying more than their fair share of taxes but perhaps that is as a result of their share of the wealth is increasing. If we want a fair and just society we need have more workers earning salaries that allow them to pay taxes to support the development of better education, better health care and better infrastructure. Research and history demonstrates that increased poverty, increased inequalities amongst people will result in increased health issues, increased crime and a decrease in the safety of a society. Helping families, helping put people to work reduces poverty and child poverty.
At the same time, the report shows 89% of Canadians agree that people in poverty deserve a helping hand and 81 per cent say helping poor families sets up their children for success. Almost all (96%) agree that everyone deserves a sense of dignity, though just 65% believe being poor robs people of their dignity.
Survey finds many Canadians believe poor are ‘part of the problem’
The rhetoric we always hear is that we don’t have the money to pay better salaries or benefits. Let’s go back to the point about the growing wealth of the top 1% of our population. The money is still there it is just not being reinvested into creating a fair and just society. Donating to food banks is one thing but in reality we need to put people back to work with good paying jobs. The old expression of give a man a fish feed for a day, teach him how to fish and you feed him for a life time fits here. Working people spend their money locally, in the stores, on consumer goods and drive the economy. Working Canadians will make for healthier and happier citizens. It is about win, win. As our former Bank of Canada Governor Mark Carney stated in 2012 there is a lot of ‘dead money’. Money that is not working for us.
Bank of Canada Governor Mark Carney has taken a rare swing at corporate Canada, accusing companies of sitting on huge piles of “dead money” that should be invested productively or returned to investors.
Whenever one comes and speaks out about fairness and equality for everyone or talks about our basic human rights we are often seen as socialists or communists or heaven forbid in cahoots with unions. However, in the end, this about the foundations of democracy. What was fought for during the French Revolution and their bill of rights? It is about creating societies that are fair and equal where we all have equal opportunities. Where being born poor doesn’t mean you will remain poor?
It is about policies that work for people. It is about bringing democracy back to our country.
Although Marie-Antoinette supposedly said ‘Let them eat cake’ (let them eat bread) the phrase has no real citations crediting it to her that I’ve found. However I do recall reading something once about the claim that if anything she is more likely to have said something along the lines of “laissez-les manger le gâteau trempé de fumier” i.e. “let them eat hardened dung cake” or some such – of course that was before the days of white bread…
My research agrees with yours. Some reports indicate it was not attributed to her until after the fact but others state she was taken out of context and it became the battle cry for the revolution about the total disregard the Monarchy had for the people of France. Below is an excerpt from a history site:
”—“Let them eat cake.” With that callous remark, the queen became a hated symbol of the decadent monarchy and fueled the revolution that would cause her to (literally) lose her head several years later. But did Marie-Antoinette really say those infuriating words? Not according to historians. Lady Antonia Fraser, author of a biography of the French queen, believes the quote would have been highly uncharacteristic of Marie-Antoinette, an intelligent woman who donated generously to charitable causes and, despite her own undeniably lavish lifestyle, displayed sensitivity towards the poor population of France.
Thanks for visiting my site.
Interesting parallels with our economic situation. The divide between the wealthy and those on the poverty line keeps growing. Even the ‘middle class’ groups seems to be dying!
Our governments are relying too much on mining to bridge the gap. When the demand for resources goes, what happens next? Let’s increase taxes and everyday costs. They never get it right or learn!
It is true the parellels are actually uncanny how history repeats itself. Hostory of man seems to be a constant repeat of the Ppressed and the Oppressor, I guess until we find a way to value everyone it will continue. We have so much to learn from what has already happened.